HugoScore hugoscore.org

Full review

ChatGPT / ChatGPT Health CAIHL draft report

Evidence-linked HugoScore draft report for a health AI tool that affects patients.

Agency checklist: Free · October 30, 2026

Leans expands 10 of 12 yes

Document-based draft. Independent confirmation is incomplete. Hugo has not personally verified this service.

Assessed function: ChatGPT's Health space (OpenAI), consumer use, free plan

Leans expands cap: Q11 is no, so this tool cannot reach Expands.

Astra review conflicted: OpenAI model in role record. November 10 follow-up prepared by an Anthropic model. Anthropic competes with OpenAI.

A no can mean missing documentation or institution-dependent control; it does not by itself establish harmful behavior. These categories are not clinical safety or product-quality ratings.

  • Public documents do not establish actual product behavior.
  • The independent review screened rules and selected evidence; it did not replicate all twelve answers for this tool.
  • November 10, 2026 accepted follow-up: Q1 and Q4 stay yes with quotations added, eight other yes answers gained their stored quotation, and the count is unchanged. Checked against archived captures. Prepared by Claude Fable 5.2 (Anthropic) from public documents and accepted by Hugo Campos. No second coder.
See all twelve answers and their evidence
QuestionAnswerEvidence / reviewSource and reasoning
1. Told it is AIYesdocumented
Yes retained; quotation added in November 10 document follow-up; independent confirmation incomplete
Due to the nature of our Services and artificial intelligence generally, output may not be unique Source
Services like ChatGPT generate responses by reading a user’s request and, in response, predicting the words most likely to appear next Source

Yes retained. The Terms of Use, which users accept, name artificial intelligence. The privacy policy describes responses as machine-generated. Disclosure inside the product was not checked because no product was used.

2. Operator and model maker namedYesdocumented
Yes retained; quotation added in November 10 document follow-up; independent confirmation incomplete
GPT‑5.5 Instant brought frontier health intelligence to all free users. Source

OpenAI operates it and names its own models (GPT-5.5 Instant, GPT-5.6 Sol).

3. Patient chooses to use itYesdocumented
Yes retained; quotation added in November 10 document follow-up; independent confirmation incomplete
You decide what accounts to connect and when ChatGPT can use the information connected in Health. Source

User decides what accounts to connect and when.

4. Patient sets the taskYesdocumented
Yes retained on a narrower basis in November 10 document follow-up; independent confirmation incomplete
Once your data is synced in Health, you can ask questions using that data anywhere in ChatGPT. Source
For Free and Go users, to personalize the ads you see on our Services Source

Yes retained on a narrower basis. The source shows the user poses their own questions. No source says the operator does not steer. The Free plan shows advertising, which is counted under Q12 and is not counted a second time here. The Health tab offers suggested prompts. An earlier note mentioned proactive updates. That wording is not in the cited capture and is withdrawn.

5. Patient can decline or stopYesdocumented
Yes retained; quotation added in November 10 document follow-up; independent confirmation incomplete
You are free to stop using our Services at any time. Source

Free to stop using the Services at any time.

6. Patient sees the AI outputYesdocumented
Yes retained; quotation added in November 10 document follow-up; independent confirmation incomplete
Return to Health anytime to see recent data and trends, find suggested prompts, browse synced records, revisit past conversations, and manage your connected accounts. Source

Patient sees answers and can revisit past conversations.

7. Patient can correct or challengeYesdocumented
Yes retained; quotation added in November 10 document follow-up; independent confirmation incomplete
you would like to request a correction or removal of the information, you can submit these requests through privacy.openai.com Source

Correction request route for inaccurate output about the user; in-product correction of out-of-date information.

8. Patient can get a copyYesdocumented
Yes retained; quotation added in November 10 document follow-up; independent confirmation incomplete
OpenAI offers choices, including options to export or delete your Personal Data, through our Privacy Portal Source

Export through the Privacy Portal, including Health data.

9. Patient can deleteYesdocumented
Yes retained; quotation added in November 10 document follow-up; independent confirmation incomplete
You can delete any conversations or memories, including within your main ChatGPT account or within ChatGPT Health, at any time. Source

Conversations and memories can be deleted at any time.

10. Training or sale does not override patient choiceYesdocumented
Yes retained; quotation added in November 10 document follow-up; independent confirmation incomplete
Connected medical records and Apple Health information, and conversations that use it, are not used to train our foundation models or target ads Source

Connected records and conversations using them are not used to train foundation models; training opt-out for other chats.

11. Patient can run it or take it elsewhereNonot-documented
Not independently replicated
OpenAI offers choices, including options to export or delete your Personal Data, through our Privacy Portal Source

Export of data is documented. Running the function yourself or moving it to another provider is not. The health help article also says synced data is deleted within 30 days of disconnecting.

12. No advertising or data businessNodocumented
Not independently replicated
For Free and Go users, to personalize the ads you see on our Services (subject to your settings) Source

OpenAI documents an advertising business. Health is available to Free and Go users. The health help article says connected records and conversations that use them are not used to train foundation models or target ads. The health notice says OpenAI does not sell Personal Data. The ad policy bars ads on mental and personal health conversations. No source says the Health space itself is ad-free. The privacy policy also says OpenAI aggregates or de-identifies Personal Data and shares it with third parties, and shares limited data with marketing partners.

Initial coding: Claude Sonnet helpers, compiled by Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic). Selective review and corrections: GPT-6 Astra (OpenAI). Editor: Hugo Campos. Acceptance of corrections is not product verification.

Checklist rules · Independent review and limitations · Later evidence follow-up

Agency checklist: Plus · October 30, 2026

Leans expands 10 of 12 yes

Document-based draft. Independent confirmation is incomplete. Hugo has not personally verified this service.

Assessed function: ChatGPT Health on a paid plan (ChatGPT Plus). Questions 11 and 12 only.

Leans expands cap: Q11 is no, so this tool cannot reach Expands.

Astra review conflicted: OpenAI model in role record. November 10 follow-up prepared by an Anthropic model. Anthropic competes with OpenAI.

A no can mean missing documentation or institution-dependent control; it does not by itself establish harmful behavior. These categories are not clinical safety or product-quality ratings.

  • Only Q11 and Q12 were separately coded for Plus; Q1 to Q10 inherit the main checklist.
  • Plus availability and complete plan-specific equivalence were not verified. This is a provisional document-based comparison.
See all twelve answers and their evidence
QuestionAnswerEvidence / reviewSource and reasoning
1. Told it is AIYesdocumented
Not independently replicated for this plan
Due to the nature of our Services and artificial intelligence generally, output may not be unique Source
Services like ChatGPT generate responses by reading a user’s request and, in response, predicting the words most likely to appear next Source

Inherited from the main ChatGPT Health checklist; not independently rechecked for Plus. Yes retained. The Terms of Use, which users accept, name artificial intelligence. The privacy policy describes responses as machine-generated. Disclosure inside the product was not checked because no product was used.

2. Operator and model maker namedYesdocumented
Not independently replicated for this plan
GPT‑5.5 Instant brought frontier health intelligence to all free users. Source

Inherited from the main ChatGPT Health checklist; not independently rechecked for Plus. OpenAI operates it and names its own models (GPT-5.5 Instant, GPT-5.6 Sol).

3. Patient chooses to use itYesdocumented
Not independently replicated for this plan
You decide what accounts to connect and when ChatGPT can use the information connected in Health. Source

Inherited from the main ChatGPT Health checklist; not independently rechecked for Plus. User decides what accounts to connect and when.

4. Patient sets the taskYesdocumented
Not independently replicated for this plan
Once your data is synced in Health, you can ask questions using that data anywhere in ChatGPT. Source
For Free and Go users, to personalize the ads you see on our Services Source

Inherited from the main ChatGPT Health checklist; not independently rechecked for Plus. Yes retained on a narrower basis. The source shows the user poses their own questions. No source says the operator does not steer. The Free plan shows advertising, which is counted under Q12 and is not counted a second time here. The Health tab offers suggested prompts. An earlier note mentioned proactive updates. That wording is not in the cited capture and is withdrawn.

5. Patient can decline or stopYesdocumented
Not independently replicated for this plan
You are free to stop using our Services at any time. Source

Inherited from the main ChatGPT Health checklist; not independently rechecked for Plus. Free to stop using the Services at any time.

6. Patient sees the AI outputYesdocumented
Not independently replicated for this plan
Return to Health anytime to see recent data and trends, find suggested prompts, browse synced records, revisit past conversations, and manage your connected accounts. Source

Inherited from the main ChatGPT Health checklist; not independently rechecked for Plus. Patient sees answers and can revisit past conversations.

7. Patient can correct or challengeYesdocumented
Not independently replicated for this plan
you would like to request a correction or removal of the information, you can submit these requests through privacy.openai.com Source

Inherited from the main ChatGPT Health checklist; not independently rechecked for Plus. Correction request route for inaccurate output about the user; in-product correction of out-of-date information.

8. Patient can get a copyYesdocumented
Not independently replicated for this plan
OpenAI offers choices, including options to export or delete your Personal Data, through our Privacy Portal Source

Inherited from the main ChatGPT Health checklist; not independently rechecked for Plus. Export through the Privacy Portal, including Health data.

9. Patient can deleteYesdocumented
Not independently replicated for this plan
You can delete any conversations or memories, including within your main ChatGPT account or within ChatGPT Health, at any time. Source

Inherited from the main ChatGPT Health checklist; not independently rechecked for Plus. Conversations and memories can be deleted at any time.

10. Training or sale does not override patient choiceYesdocumented
Not independently replicated for this plan
Connected medical records and Apple Health information, and conversations that use it, are not used to train our foundation models or target ads Source

Inherited from the main ChatGPT Health checklist; not independently rechecked for Plus. Connected records and conversations using them are not used to train foundation models; training opt-out for other chats.

11. Patient can run it or take it elsewhereNonot-documented
Not independently replicated for this plan
Quotation not recorded; evidence repair pending.

ChatGPT is vendor-hosted. The privacy policy and health notice document export and deletion through account data controls and the Privacy Portal, which is export alone. Nothing documents running it yourself or moving the same function elsewhere without OpenAI.

12. No advertising or data businessNodocumented
Not independently replicated for this plan
aggregate or de-identify Personal Data so that it no longer identifies you and share it with third parties Source

Privacy policy (updated Sept 10, 2026) section 3. It also says 'We don't "sell" Personal Data' and the Health Privacy Notice says 'We do not sell Personal Data of our users, including any Personal Data collected via Health Features.' Ads are limited to Free and Go users, so Plus sees none in the product. But the policy also documents sharing 'limited data with select marketing partners' for cross-context behavioral advertising of OpenAI's own products (opt-out in account settings), and sharing de-identified data with third parties.

Initial coding: Claude Sonnet helpers, compiled by Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic). Selective review and corrections: GPT-6 Astra (OpenAI). Editor: Hugo Campos. Acceptance of corrections is not product verification.

Checklist rules · Independent review and limitations · Later evidence follow-up

Earlier report

ChatGPT / ChatGPT Health: CAIHL reassessment

September 8, 2026. Published AI-assisted draft.

ChatGPT’s documented Health controls include permissions for connected data and editable current context. Source records remain read-only. Source disconnection, conversation deletion, memories, ordinary-chat settings, and the legacy Health project have distinct boundaries.

Scope and agency posture

Consumer Health connections and ordinary ChatGPT health use must be distinguished, as must the legacy Health project. Preserve the August 9 baseline 75 and prior Claude provenance.

Posture: Potentially agency-expanding, with platform-custody caveat.

Axis: 75/100, retained provisionally. No numerical recalibration was performed.

Sources and documented findings

  • The current Health help page documents permission before connected-data use by default, adjustable permissions, editable current conditions/medications/family history, and read-only source records. Earlier Health chats and files remain in a project whose memories stay within it. Current access documentation names web and iOS, not Android.
  • The July launch page says disconnected-source data is deleted within 30 days, while content already in conversations remains until those conversations are deleted. Conversations using connected medical records or Apple Health are excluded from foundation-model training and ad targeting. Ordinary conversations follow account training settings. Health conversations can create memories, which require separate controls.
  • The Health Privacy Notice separately permits limited authorized personnel and service-provider access for model-safety improvement unless opted out, and provides an export/deletion rights route. Its older dedicated-Health and Connect Health wording needs to be read alongside current product documentation, not silently replaced by a blanket no-access promise.
  • The prior report's lawsuit narratives, usage figures and paid-model claims were not refreshed in this focused controls pass. They remain historical, unverified here, and are not used to determine this recommendation.

Patient authority

Inference from the documented workflow: Patients can set questions and goals, amend current context and decide when linked information is consulted. They cannot alter the provider's source record through Health. These are meaningful controls within a vendor-controlled platform, rather than evidence that every health record automatically informs every chat.

Critical capacity

Editorial assessment: Follow-up, correction of current context and record-grounded comparison can support reasoning. Editing context does not guarantee correction of future model errors or an investigation of a harmful answer. Connected outputs still need evidence and uncertainty scrutiny.

Informed control

Editorial assessment: The baseline overstates the loss of separation and understates permission controls. Users must distinguish source disconnection, conversation deletion, memories and ordinary-chat training settings. Safety access is a separate published condition from foundation-model training.

Assessment and limits

Replace the categorical architecture-loss narrative with the documented permission, legacy-project and retention boundaries. The platform-custody caveat remains justified, but these controls materially qualify it. No numerical recalibration is established.

Confidence: Medium for official published controls, limited for execution.

Remaining uncertainty: No live connection, permission, memory or deletion test. Litigation and independent safety validation were not refreshed.

Published documentation is evidence of stated conditions, not proof of actual implementation. Unknowns did not receive automatic negative points. Funding, sponsorship, and public code do not determine agency by themselves.

Review provenance

  • Reviewer/model: OpenAI Codex / GPT-6.
  • Method: Focused public-source reassessment using CAIHL: patient authority, critical capacity, and informed control. Existing evidence plus one focused primary-source pass and at most one targeted follow-up. No live product testing. Numerical scores remain provisional editorial placements, not a new calculation.
  • Human review: Hugo Campos authorized publication of these AI-assisted draft reassessments on September 8, 2026. This does not claim comprehensive human verification of every finding.
  • Earlier review: 2026-08-09. Historical assessment. Earlier claims are not automatically reverified by this publication.